Dealer Reviews

Is APMEX Legit? The Biggest Catalog, Pricier Gold and Some Cheap Silver Days

BullionMetric rating: 3.5 out of 5 · Scored on our tracking for July 13 – October 11, 2026 · Price figures in this review run through October 11, 2026 · How we rate dealers →

By BullionMetric

Disclosure. BullionMetric has no affiliate or commercial relationship with any dealer named on this page, and no dealer pays for placement or rankings. If we join affiliate programs in the future, we'll say so on this page and on our affiliate disclosure page, with the date it began.

About this review. BullionMetric records the price and stock status of every listing at the major US online bullion dealers, most days of the week. This review uses our tracking from July 13 to October 11, 2026, measured against an independent reference spot price rather than each dealer's own displayed spot. BBB, Trustpilot, shipping, company and court facts were checked on November 13, 2026. Fees, returns and IRA terms are from our June 2026 check and are marked that way. How we track premiums →

Updated November 13, 2026. We rewrote the price sections with data from July 13 to October 11, 2026. Our method changed since June: premiums are now measured against one independent spot price, and random-year and specific-year coins are compared separately. Two conclusions moved:

  • Our June version said APMEX was never the cheapest dealer on any flagship coin. Under the current method that was wrong. Among dealers that keep stock, it was the cheapest on some days for random-year Silver Maple Leafs, random-year Silver Eagles and Pre-1933 gold double eagles.
  • It said JM Bullion was typically cheaper on Eagles and Maples. It's closer than that: on the same product on the same day, JM was cheaper 51.4% of the time and APMEX 48.6%.
  • It said there was no litigation against APMEX on public record. That was wrong: a federal antitrust case, A World Trade, Inc. v. Apmex, Inc., was filed in 2020 and terminated in 2021.

We also removed the specialty-coin price wins and the stock-by-year table, which the current method doesn't support. We re-checked APMEX's BBB and Trustpilot profiles, shipping and About pages, and the federal court docket on November 13, 2026. Fees, returns and IRA terms are still from June 2026. Details are in How we measured this.

The short answer

Yes, APMEX is a legitimate bullion dealer: it has sold from Oklahoma City since 2000 and holds an A+ BBB rating. It has the deepest catalog we track, 5,867 gold and silver products, including 2,690 graded coins, 5.38 times as many as the next dealer. On the gold coins most people buy, you usually pay more there: a random-year Gold Eagle ran $93.43 more over spot than at SD Bullion, and APMEX was never the cheapest on random-year Gold Eagles, Maple Leafs or Buffalos. On random-year silver it was sometimes the cheapest dealer with stock, on 13 of 41 days for Silver Maple Leafs and 11 of 41 for Silver Eagles, though Kitco was cheapest more often. Use APMEX for graded coins, hard-to-find issues and the occasional silver deal, and price-check it on everything else.

The biggest catalog we track

No other dealer we follow comes close on selection. Over the last month of our window, APMEX listed 5,867 gold and silver products: 3,722 gold and 2,145 silver.

DealerGold and silver products listed
APMEX5,867
JM Bullion2,576
Hero Bullion1,095
Median of the eleven dealers we track665

Graded coins are the real moat. APMEX listed 2,690 PCGS, NGC, ANACS and ICG graded products. That's 5.38 times BullionExchanges, the next-largest, and 149 times Money Metals Exchange. If you want certified coins from a large online dealer, APMEX is close to the only choice at that depth.

The IRA business. As of June 2026, APMEX worked with four IRA custodians (The Entrust Group, GoldStar Trust Company, Equity Institutional and STRATA Trust Company), had a $2,000 IRA minimum, and stored metal through Citadel Global Depository Services, an APMEX subsidiary using Brink's facilities, at 0.45%–0.55% a year plus $180–$550 in annual fees. If you want dealer, custodian and vault under one relationship, APMEX offers more of that than most peers.

The gaps. We couldn't compare APMEX on 1 oz gold bars, junk silver or generic silver rounds. It had no listing that matched our definitions for those products during the window.

Where APMEX is the cheapest

Here's how often APMEX had the lowest median price among the main dealers we compare, on days it had the product in stock:

Product (1 oz unless noted)APMEX cheapestUsually cheapest
Silver Maple Leaf, random year13 of 41 daysKitco
Silver Eagle, random year11 of 41 daysKitco
Pre-1933 gold double eagle10 of 59 daysJM Bullion
Gold Buffalo, specific year9 of 68 daysProvident Metals
Gold Philharmonic, specific year6 of 61 daysProvident Metals
Krugerrand, random year2 of 70 daysMoney Metals Exchange
Gold Eagle, specific year0 of 69 days (second on 31)SD Bullion
Gold Eagle, random year0 of 69 daysSD Bullion
Gold Maple Leaf, random year0 of 70 daysHero Bullion
Gold Buffalo, random year0 of 70 daysSD Bullion
100 oz silver bar0 of 41 daysHero Bullion

Random-year Silver Maple Leafs are APMEX's best showing. It was cheapest on 13 of 41 days, second only to Kitco. That result holds even when we add the dealers that rarely have stock.

Random-year Silver Eagles and Pre-1933 gold come with a caveat. APMEX was cheapest on 11 of 41 and 10 of 59 days among dealers that keep stock. Add every dealer and it drops to zero on both: GoldenStateMint posts lower Silver Eagle prices, but its stock signal is unverified, and BullionExchanges posts lower Pre-1933 prices but has the lowest in-stock rate of any dealer we track. If you only count dealers that reliably have stock, APMEX's wins stand. Either way, Kitco and JM Bullion won those products more often.

Specific-year Gold Eagles are a near miss. APMEX was never the cheapest, but it was second on 31 of 69 days. SD Bullion was cheaper every day we compared.

Modern random-year gold is where APMEX loses. It was never the cheapest on random-year Gold Eagles, Gold Maple Leafs or Gold Buffalos, and won just 2 of 70 days on Krugerrands.

Winning a quarter to a third of the silver days doesn't make APMEX's typical silver price low. Check the day's price rather than assume.

What the extra costs you

Here's the gap in dollars, against the cheapest of the main dealers, using median prices over spot from July 13 to October 11, 2026:

OrderAPMEX over spotCheapest main dealerAPMEX costs you more
One random-year Gold Buffalo$316.58SD Bullion$152.60
One random-year Gold Eagle$216.19SD Bullion, $122.76$93.43
One random-year Gold Maple Leaf$166.09Hero Bullion$84.02
One random-year Krugerrand$155.63Money Metals Exchange$83.18
One 100 oz silver bar$8.74/ozHero Bullion, $3.62/oz$512
A tube of twenty random-year Silver Eagles$14.44/ozMoney Metals Exchange$68.40 ($3.42/oz)

On the popular gold coins, that's $83.18 to $152.60 a coin. On silver the per-ounce gap looks small, but it adds up: $512 on a single 100 oz bar.

Same coin, same day

Against JM Bullion, it's close to even. Across 2,510 cases where both dealers had the same product in stock on the same day, JM was cheaper 51.4% of the time and APMEX 48.6%. The split depends on the coin:

  • APMEX was cheaper on specific-year Gold Eagles and Gold Maple Leafs. Gold Eagles: $261.49 vs $281.59 at JM. Gold Maple Leafs: $195.14 vs $209.01.
  • APMEX was slightly cheaper on random-year silver. Silver Eagles: $14.44 vs $14.60. Silver Maple Leafs: $9.95 vs $10.66.
  • JM was cheaper on random-year gold coins.

Against Hero Bullion, it isn't close: Hero was cheaper in 97.5% of same-product, same-day comparisons. Against SD Bullion it was close to even: APMEX was cheaper in 49.3% of them, 52.2% on silver and 44.4% on gold. SD was much cheaper on random-year Gold Eagles and Buffalos, as the table above shows.

Steady on Gold Eagles

APMEX's random-year Gold Eagle price barely moved. Its daily median sat around 5.00% over spot, with a standard deviation of 0.54 points. Our June review said all of APMEX's flagship prices were set and stable. That still holds for the random-year Gold Eagle. We haven't re-measured the other products.

Stock: better than the headline on the coins people buy

Over the last month of our window, 27.8% of APMEX's gold and silver listings were in stock. That looks low next to Money Metals Exchange at 87.5%, but it's ahead of JM Bullion at 24.8%. And the headline is mostly the long tail of the catalog:

APMEX listingsIn stock
Standard bullion lines and bars32.6%
Everything else21.1%
Collectible and series coins15.8%
All gold and silver27.8%

The coins most people buy were always there. APMEX's random-year Gold Eagle, Gold Maple Leaf, Gold Buffalo, Krugerrand, Silver Eagle, Silver Maple Leaf and Silver Britannia each had at least one listing in stock on every day we saw them in that month (24 of 24 days for the Gold Eagle, 23 of 23 for the rest). Pre-1933 gold, 100 oz bars and 10 oz bars always had at least one listing in stock too.

Our June review said more than half of APMEX's current-production listings were in stock. That came from a year-bucket split we no longer use, and it doesn't hold under the current method. APMEX's standard lines run under five points above its whole catalog, not the wide gap we described in June.

Can you trust them?

Company. APMEX, Inc. was founded in 2000 by Scott Thomas, who started by selling pieces of his grandfather's coin collection on eBay. BBB lists it as 26 years in business. As of our June 2026 check, it was based at 226 Dean A. McGee Avenue in Oklahoma City, in the former Federal Reserve Bank building, with about 300 employees, and Kenneth (Ken) Lewis was CEO. In 2023, the Swiss refiner MKS PAMP Group made a strategic investment; APMEX remains private and operates independently. In June, APMEX said it had served 1.8 million customers and handled more than $20 billion in transactions. Its About page now claims more than 20,000 products and a 98% customer satisfaction rating. Those are APMEX's own figures, not ours; we track 5,867 of its gold and silver products.

BBB. Rated A+ and accredited since April 29, 2004. The profile shows 261 complaints in the last 3 years, 140 of them in the past year, and 200 customer reviews. That's a high count, as you'd expect from a dealer this size. In June, most complaints we read showed APMEX responding with a refund, replacement or explanation.

Trustpilot. 4.4 out of 5 from 10,573 reviews. APMEX pays for a Trustpilot subscription and invites its customers to leave reviews.

APMEX admitted service problems. In February 2026, CEO Ken Lewis published an open letter acknowledging "service levels that are not up to the APMEX standard" after the late-2025 demand surge slowed shipping.

What Reddit complains about. On r/Silverbugs, r/Gold and r/Bullion, most posts about APMEX are routine. The complaints cluster around five things: shipping delays in late 2025 and early 2026, lost packages where insurance was denied because signature wasn't required, sell-back offers that felt low, cancellation fees, and slow customer service on disputes. A separate set of posts in February and March 2026 alleged counterfeit silver bars. As of June we found no confirmation or pattern, but the allegations are public.

Litigation. A World Trade, Inc. v. Apmex, Inc., No. 2:20-cv-01032, was filed in the US District Court for the Central District of California on January 31, 2020, as an antitrust case. The docket shows it terminated on February 22, 2021. We haven't read the outcome. We searched CourtListener for this update but not every court database, so other cases may exist.

Shipping, payment, returns, IRA

Shipping costs and timing were checked on November 13, 2026. Rows marked June are from our June 2026 check; confirm them at checkout.

APMEX
Free shippingUS orders over $199; $9.95 below that
When it shipsWithin 3 business days of confirmed payment for non-QuickShip orders paid by card, wire, PayPal or Bitcoin
QuickShipWithin one business day of payment clearing, for QuickShip items paid by card or wire (restrictions apply); a $10 coupon if it misses (June)
Personal check and eCheckHeld 4 to 6 business days after payment is processed
CarriersUSPS, UPS, FedEx (June)
SignatureNot required by default. Opt in at checkout (June)
Lost packageNotify within 30 days of shipment (June)
Damage or tamperingNotify within 2 business days of delivery (June)
Check, eCheck and wire4% less than the card price (June)
Card, PayPal, crypto (BitPay)Accepted at the full list price (June)
ReturnsNotify within 7 days of receipt (June)
Restocking fee5% on card returns; $50 minimum on some categories (June)
Cancellation$35 plus any market loss (June)
Selling to APMEX$1,000 minimum (June)
IRA$2,000 minimum; about 10,000 IRA-eligible products (June)
The Bullion CardCo-branded credit card, 4% back in metals on APMEX purchases (June)

Two points matter more than the rest:

  • Opt in to a signature. APMEX's terms exclude insurance coverage when a package is delivered without a signature and then goes missing. It comes up again and again in complaints, and it's easy to avoid.
  • Pay by wire. As of June, APMEX's list prices were card prices, and paying by check, eCheck or wire saved 4%, which can be worth more than the gap to a cheaper dealer on a small order. A wire avoids the 4 to 6 business day hold on personal checks and eChecks.

Should you buy from APMEX?

Find your line:

  • Graded or certified coins: yes, start here. 2,690 graded products, 5.38 times the next dealer.
  • Hard-to-find series and specialty issues: yes, often by default. That's availability, not a price win.
  • A precious metals IRA with custody and storage in one place: a reasonable fit. The same price gaps apply to IRA-eligible coins.
  • Random-year Silver Maple Leafs or Silver Eagles: check APMEX the day you buy. It was cheapest on 13 of 41 and 11 of 41 days, but its typical price was higher than the cheapest dealers': Money Metals Exchange on Silver Eagles, Hero Bullion and Kitco on Silver Maple Leafs.
  • Specific-year Gold Eagles or Gold Maple Leafs: compare first. For Gold Eagles, check SD Bullion and BGASC; for Gold Maple Leafs, BGASC. APMEX beat JM Bullion on both, but it wasn't the cheapest.
  • Pre-1933 gold double eagles: JM Bullion first. APMEX was cheapest on 10 of 59 days; JM won far more often, at $79.42 over gold value to APMEX's $91.02.
  • Random-year Gold Eagles, Maple Leafs, Buffalos or Krugerrands: no. SD Bullion, Hero Bullion and Money Metals Exchange were $83.18 to $152.60 a coin cheaper. See our SD Bullion review, Hero Bullion review and Money Metals Exchange review.
  • 100 oz silver bars: no. About $512 more per bar than Hero Bullion.
  • Choosing between APMEX and JM Bullion: close to a coin flip. JM was cheaper on the same product 51.4% of the time. See our JM Bullion review.
  • Paying by card: think twice. The 4% card price difference can be bigger than the gap you're trying to avoid.

The verdict

APMEX is a legitimate, long-established dealer, and nothing in our data or the records we checked suggests otherwise. It has the deepest catalog of any dealer we track and is close to the only large online source for graded coins.

It isn't the cheap option on the gold coins most people buy. A random-year Gold Eagle cost $93.43 more over spot than at SD Bullion, and a random-year Gold Buffalo $152.60 more. It's not always the expensive option either. It was the cheapest on about a third of the days for random-year Silver Maple Leafs, and it beat JM Bullion on specific-year Gold Eagles and Gold Maple Leafs.

The limits: a strict signature and insurance policy, a card price 4% above check and wire (as of June), a cancellation fee, and service problems in early 2026 that its CEO acknowledged publicly.

So here's how we'd use it. Buy graded coins and hard-to-find issues here. On random-year silver, check APMEX alongside Kitco and Money Metals Exchange on the day. On modern gold coins, start with SD Bullion and Hero Bullion. Pay by wire, and opt in to a signature.

Before you order, check today's prices across every dealer we track. A median tells you who's usually cheapest. Today's price tells you who's cheapest now.

Related: Is JM Bullion legit? · Is SD Bullion legit? · Is Hero Bullion legit? · Is Money Metals Exchange legit? · Is Bullion Exchanges legit? · How we rate dealers · How much over spot should you pay for gold? · How much over spot for silver?

FAQ

Is APMEX a real company?

Yes. APMEX, Inc. has sold bullion from Oklahoma City since 2000. It holds an A+ BBB rating and has been BBB-accredited since April 29, 2004. MKS PAMP Group made a strategic investment in it in 2023.

Is APMEX overpriced?

On most gold coins, yes. A random-year Gold Eagle cost $93.43 more over spot than at SD Bullion from July to October 2026. On random-year silver it was sometimes the cheapest, on 13 of 41 days for Silver Maple Leafs.

Has anyone been scammed by APMEX?

The federal case we found on CourtListener, A World Trade, Inc. v. Apmex, Inc., was an antitrust suit, terminated in 2021. BBB complaints, 261 in 3 years, center on lost packages, shipping delays, sell-back offers and fees.

Where does APMEX ship from?

Oklahoma City, by USPS, UPS or FedEx. Shipments are insured, but as of June 2026 a signature wasn't required by default. Opt in at checkout: APMEX's terms exclude coverage for unsigned deliveries that go missing.

Does APMEX report to the IRS?

Not when you buy; a purchase isn't a reportable event. When you sell certain bullion back in reportable quantities, dealers including APMEX file Form 1099-B. Gold and Silver Eagles aren't on that list.

Is APMEX's silver and gold real?

APMEX buys from major mints and authorized distributors and offers an authenticity guarantee. Some posts in early 2026 alleged counterfeit silver bars; we found no confirmed pattern. A scale and calipers are cheap insurance anywhere.

How long has APMEX been in business?

26 years. Scott Thomas founded APMEX in Oklahoma City in 2000, starting with coins from his grandfather's collection. It has been BBB-accredited since April 29, 2004.

Is APMEX cheaper than JM Bullion or SD Bullion?

Against JM it's close: on the same product on the same day, JM was cheaper 51.4% of the time. SD Bullion was much cheaper on random-year Gold Eagles, $122.76 over spot against APMEX's $216.19.

What is APMEX's BBB rating?

A+, with BBB accreditation since April 29, 2004. The profile shows 261 complaints in the last 3 years, 140 of them in the past year, which is a high count even for a dealer this size.

How we measured this

BullionMetric records the listed price and stock status of every tracked product at US online dealers most days. Eleven dealers are tracked: APMEX, BGASC, BullionExchanges, GoldenStateMint, Hero Bullion, JM Bullion, Kitco, Money Metals Exchange, Provident Metals, SD Bullion and SilverGoldBull. We've tracked APMEX since June 4, 2025.

Window. July 13 to October 11, 2026. We recorded APMEX on 76 days. No prices were collected for any dealer from Sep 29 – Oct 2, because of a data-collection outage. On some days we captured only part of APMEX's catalog, so its counts use only days we tracked its full catalog for that metal: 70 gold days and 55 silver days.

Main dealers. Rankings compare the dealers with enough stock to compare: APMEX, BGASC, Hero Bullion, JM Bullion, Money Metals Exchange, Provident Metals and SD Bullion, plus Kitco for silver. GoldenStateMint is left out because its stock signal is unverified. BullionExchanges and SilverGoldBull are left out because fewer than one in ten of their listings were in stock.

Day counts. A day counts when at least three main dealers had the product in stock. Gold uses the whole window. Silver starts in late August, when we first fully tracked Hero Bullion's silver. Ties count as a win for each tied dealer.

A check on the day count. On a stricter basis that uses only the days every dealer was fully tracked, APMEX was cheapest on 5 of 19 days for random-year Silver Eagles and for Silver Maple Leafs, and 5 of 32 for Pre-1933 gold. The usual winners didn't change, and APMEX still never won a day on random-year Gold Eagles, Maple Leafs or Buffalos.

Medians and spot. Dollar medians use every in-stock observation in the window. Premiums are measured against an independent reference spot price. The in-stock rates cover the last month of the window, through October 11.

What's included. In-stock listings with premiums between 0% and 300%. Products: 1 oz coins, 10 oz and 100 oz silver bars, and Pre-1933 gold double eagles.

What's excluded. Graded and certified coins, proofs and special finishes, privy and limited editions, listings marked off-quality, gift packaging, and multi-coin tubes, rolls and boxes.

Random year and specific year. "Random year" means listings sold as random year. For coins other than Silver Eagles, it also includes listings that state no year. Specific-year listings are compared separately.

What changed since June. Our first review, published in June 2026, used data through June. It measured premiums against each dealer's own displayed spot, mixed every year of a coin into one price, and counted every dealer as a competitor. It also reported price wins on specialty coins (Polar Bears, Ducats, Tudor Beasts, Queen's Beasts, Libertads) that our current product groups don't cover, so we've removed them. This version replaces those findings. Full methodology →

Last updated: November 13, 2026. Premium data through October 11, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Is APMEX a real company?

Yes. APMEX, Inc. has sold bullion from Oklahoma City since 2000. It holds an A+ BBB rating and has been BBB-accredited since April 29, 2004. MKS PAMP Group made a strategic investment in it in 2023.

Is APMEX overpriced?

On most gold coins, yes. A random-year Gold Eagle cost $93.43 more over spot than at SD Bullion from July to October 2026. On random-year silver it was sometimes the cheapest, on 13 of 41 days for Silver Maple Leafs.

Has anyone been scammed by APMEX?

The federal case we found on CourtListener, A World Trade, Inc. v. Apmex, Inc., was an antitrust suit, terminated in 2021. BBB complaints, 261 in 3 years, center on lost packages, shipping delays, sell-back offers and fees.

Where does APMEX ship from?

Oklahoma City, by USPS, UPS or FedEx. Shipments are insured, but as of June 2026 a signature wasn't required by default. Opt in at checkout: APMEX's terms exclude coverage for unsigned deliveries that go missing.

Does APMEX report to the IRS?

Not when you buy; a purchase isn't a reportable event. When you sell certain bullion back in reportable quantities, dealers including APMEX file Form 1099-B. Gold and Silver Eagles aren't on that list.

Is APMEX's silver and gold real?

APMEX buys from major mints and authorized distributors and offers an authenticity guarantee. Some posts in early 2026 alleged counterfeit silver bars; we found no confirmed pattern. A scale and calipers are cheap insurance anywhere.

How long has APMEX been in business?

26 years. Scott Thomas founded APMEX in Oklahoma City in 2000, starting with coins from his grandfather's collection. It has been BBB-accredited since April 29, 2004.

Is APMEX cheaper than JM Bullion or SD Bullion?

Against JM it's close: on the same product on the same day, JM was cheaper 51.4% of the time. SD Bullion was much cheaper on random-year Gold Eagles, $122.76 over spot against APMEX's $216.19.

What is APMEX's BBB rating?

A+, with BBB accreditation since April 29, 2004. The profile shows 261 complaints in the last 3 years, 140 of them in the past year, which is a high count even for a dealer this size.

Compare prices by coin: Gold Eagle prices and premiums · Silver Eagle prices and premiums · Gold Maple Leaf prices and premiums · Krugerrand prices and premiums