Dealer Reviews

Is Bullion Exchanges Legit? The Lowest Gold Prices We Track, on the Few Listings in Stock

BullionMetric rating: 3.5 out of 5 · Scored on our tracking for July 13 – October 11, 2026 · Price figures in this review run through October 11, 2026 · How we rate dealers →

By BullionMetric

Disclosure. BullionMetric has no affiliate or commercial relationship with any dealer named on this page, and no dealer pays for placement or rankings. If we join affiliate programs in the future, we'll say so on this page and on our affiliate disclosure page, with the date it began.

About this review. BullionMetric records the price and stock status of every listing at the major US online bullion dealers, most days of the week. This review uses our tracking from July 13 to October 11, 2026, measured against an independent reference spot price rather than each dealer's own displayed spot. Our tracking of Bullion Exchanges covers its gold only. Company, policy and legal facts come from its BBB profile, public filings and court records linked in each section. How we track premiums →

Updated November 18, 2026. We rewrote this review with our tracking from July 13 to October 11, 2026. Premiums are now measured against an independent reference spot price, coins are split into random-year and specific-year listings, and a "cheapest" day counts only when Bullion Exchanges' listing was in stock. Two conclusions moved:

  • The June version said Krugerrands were the one product where Bullion Exchanges' low prices were actually buyable, and that it lost Gold Eagles to GoldenStateMint, whose stock data is unverified. Under the current method it was the cheapest in-stock dealer on random-year Gold Eagles, random-year Krugerrands, 1 oz gold bars and Pre-1933 $20 gold on most days.
  • The June version said Bullion Exchanges is run by BX Corporation, a Gold.com subsidiary, and is JM Bullion's sister company. That was wrong. Gold.com's annual reports identify BX Corporation as BullionMax, and one of them names Bullion Exchanges as a JM Bullion competitor.

It also said a federal lawsuit ended with Bullion Exchanges winning summary judgment. We haven't confirmed how that case ended, so we've taken that out. Details are in How we measured this.

The short answer

Yes, Bullion Exchanges is a legitimate bullion dealer: a New York store in business since 2012, rated A+ and accredited by the BBB since 2015, with a 4.5 TrustScore from 1,364 Trustpilot reviews. On price, it was the cheapest dealer we track on random-year Gold Eagles (58 of 65 days), random-year Krugerrands (46 of 48), 1 oz gold bars (72 of 74) and Pre-1933 $20 gold (72 of 74), counting only days its listing was in stock. Those listings were in stock often enough to use: the Gold Eagle 87.8% of the time, the Krugerrand 77.3%, the Pre-1933 coins 72.1%, and at least one 1 oz bar on 76 of 76 days. The rest of the catalog mostly wasn't: only 4.9% of all its listings were in stock over the last 30 days of the window, the lowest of any dealer we track, against 24.8% at JM Bullion. And it isn't owned by Gold.com or related to JM Bullion, as our June review said.

Here's the evidence.

The low prices, tested against the stock

Bullion Exchanges has always looked cheap on a comparison page. The question is whether the cheap listing is one you can buy. So for every product below we count a day only when its listing was in stock, rank it against every dealer we track, and put its in-stock rate right next to the result.

Product (1 oz unless noted)Bullion Exchanges cheapestDays with one in stockListings in stockMedian over spot
Gold Eagle, random year58 of 65 days65 of 74 days87.8%$61.44 (1.43%)
Krugerrand, random year46 of 48 days58 of 75 days77.3%$22.39 (0.53%)
Pre-1933 $20 gold72 of 74 days75 of 76 days72.1%$44.90 (1.11%)
1 oz gold bar72 of 74 days76 of 76 days25.6%$49.14 (1.12%)
Gold Maple Leaf, random year36 of 38 days42 of 77 days18.3%$38.47 (0.93%)
Gold Buffalo, random year33 of 41 days41 of 74 days55.4%$118.45 (2.88%)
Gold Britannia, random yearlisted lowest 74 of 75 days0never in stock—

"Cheapest" means Bullion Exchanges' median in-stock premium that day was the lowest of every dealer we track, on days its listing was in stock. "Listings in stock" is the share of its observations for that product that showed in stock across the window. Medians are the check and wire price.

Four results hold up.

Random-year Gold Eagles: cheapest, and usually there. Cheapest on 58 of the 65 days we compared, at a median of $61.44 over spot. Its random-year Eagle was in stock 87.8% of the time. Of everything Bullion Exchanges sells, this is the low price you're most likely to actually get.

Random-year Krugerrands: the same story. Cheapest on 46 of 48 days, at $22.39 over spot, in stock 77.3% of the time. Our June review had it second behind SD Bullion. Under the current method SD Bullion barely registered.

Pre-1933 $20 gold: cheapest, and the coins were there. Cheapest on 72 of 74 days at $44.90 over the coin's gold value. It had at least one in stock on 75 of 76 days. Our June review called this a toss-up between SD Bullion and Hero Bullion. It isn't.

1 oz gold bars: cheapest, if you buy the bar that's in stock. Only 25.6% of its bar listings showed in stock, but at least one bar did on 76 of 76 days, and it was cheapest on 72 of 74. Ignore the brand you wanted and buy the one that's available.

Two more come with a bigger catch.

Random-year Gold Maples: cheap when it has them. Cheapest on 36 of the 38 days we compared, at $38.47 over spot. But only 18.3% of its Maple listings were in stock, and it had one on 42 of 77 days. Expect to find it sold out about half the time.

Random-year Gold Buffalos: a split. Cheapest on 33 of the 41 days it had one in stock, at $118.45. It had none in stock on the other days. Ranked against only the dealers that usually have stock, SD Bullion was the cheapest on more days than Bullion Exchanges.

Listed cheapest, never buyable

Gold Britannias are the clearest case of a price you can't pay. Bullion Exchanges' random-year Britannia was the lowest listed price on 74 of 75 days. Its bullion Britannia listings were in stock on 0 days in the window. Over the last 30 days, 0.4% of its whole Britannia category showed in stock, and none of those were plain bullion coins. Its specific-year Krugerrands and Philharmonics were never in stock either.

If a comparison page shows Bullion Exchanges as the cheapest Britannia, it's comparing a listing, not an offer. Our June review counted it as an in-stock Britannia winner on some days. Under the current method, it never was.

What the low prices are worth

On the days the listing is in stock, the gap is large. Here it is in dollars, against the cheapest dealer that usually has stock:

OrderBullion Exchanges, median over spotCompared withBullion Exchanges saves youIts listings in stock
Ten random-year Gold Eagles$61.44/coinSD Bullion$613.2087.8%
Ten 1 oz gold bars$49.14/barHero Bullion$603.9025.6%; a bar on 76 of 76 days
Ten random-year Krugerrands$22.39/coinMoney Metals Exchange$500.6077.3%
Ten random-year Gold Maples$38.47/coinHero Bullion$436.0018.3%
Five Pre-1933 $20 gold coins$44.90/coinJM Bullion$172.6072.1%

Medians at the check and wire price, July 13 to October 11, 2026. Pay by card and you'll pay more; we couldn't open Bullion Exchanges' own site to re-check by how much.

Ten Gold Eagles for $613.20 less than the cheapest dealer that usually has stock is a real saving, and it was on offer most days. Ten Maples for $436.00 less is real too, when the coins are there, which was a minority of the time.

Stock: thin, and not just a cluttered catalog

Over the last 30 days of the window, 4.9% of Bullion Exchanges' listings were in stock. That's the lowest of the eleven dealers we track. JM Bullion was at 24.8%. Across the whole window, Bullion Exchanges was at 5.8%.

A low headline rate can be a trick of a big catalog full of sold-out collectibles. That's not what's happening here. We track 1,518 Bullion Exchanges products, all gold, the third-largest catalog we follow. Its core bullion coins and bars were in stock at about the same low rate as everything else. Current-year and random-year gold was in stock 15.5% of the time; back-year gold, 2.9%. The thin stock runs through the whole catalog.

The exceptions are the handful of listings in the table above. Bullion Exchanges keeps a random-year Gold Eagle, a random-year Krugerrand, some Pre-1933 coins and a 1 oz bar in stock most days, and prices them below everyone. Almost everything else is a listing you'll find sold out.

Graded coins: a deep catalog, little of it in stock

We track 495 graded coins at Bullion Exchanges, the second-largest graded catalog we follow after APMEX. Over the last 30 days of the window, 3.3% of them were in stock. If you collect graded coins, it's worth a search. Don't count on the coin being available. For graded coins you can actually buy, start with APMEX.

Bullion Exchanges vs APMEX and JM Bullion

vs APMEX. On the products Bullion Exchanges keeps in stock (random-year Gold Eagles, Krugerrands and Maples, 1 oz bars and Pre-1933 $20 gold), its median was lower than every dealer that usually has stock, APMEX included. APMEX has a much bigger catalog, many more graded coins and far more of its listings in stock. For a specific coin you want today, APMEX is the safer bet. For the coins in the table above, check Bullion Exchanges first. See our APMEX review.

vs JM Bullion. These are two separate companies, not sister stores (see Who owns Bullion Exchanges). On Pre-1933 $20 gold, JM Bullion is the cheapest dealer that usually has stock, cheapest on 33 of 64 days. Bullion Exchanges was cheaper still: five coins for $172.60 less at the median, with its Pre-1933 listings in stock 72.1% of the time. JM keeps far more of its catalog in stock: 24.8% of listings against 4.9%. See our JM Bullion review.

Who owns Bullion Exchanges

Bullion Exchanges, LLC is a New York company. Its BBB profile lists Ben Tseytlin as co-owner and partner and Robert Fuks as operations manager, and lists no parent company. (BBB)

Our June review said Bullion Exchanges was run by BX Corporation, a wholly owned subsidiary of Gold.com, Inc. (NYSE: GOLD, formerly A-Mark), which would make it a sister company of JM Bullion. Gold.com's own filings say otherwise. Its annual reports for fiscal 2025 and fiscal 2026 identify BX Corporation as BullionMax, a JM Bullion subsidiary. Neither lists Bullion Exchanges among Gold.com's businesses, and the fiscal 2025 report names Bullion Exchanges, with APMEX and SD Bullion, as one of JM Bullion's principal competitors. (Gold.com 10-K, fiscal 2026, Gold.com 10-K, fiscal 2025)

We found no parent company in the BBB file or Gold.com's filings. If you were choosing Bullion Exchanges because of a public parent company, there isn't one on record.

The complaints, addressed

The searches that bring people here are "is Bullion Exchanges legit," "Bullion Exchanges reviews" and "Bullion Exchanges complaints." Here's what the record says.

The BBB file: 25 complaints in three years, 7 in the last 12 months. The BBB still rates Bullion Exchanges A+, and the two newest complaints are marked answered. (BBB complaints)

Both are worth reading if you plan to order:

  • August 2026, a missing package. A buyer says a signature-required package never arrived. Bullion Exchanges replied that the carrier and its insurer found the package was delivered and signed for, so it wouldn't refund or replace it. It pointed to terms that end its liability at confirmed delivery.
  • July 2026, a spotted bar. A buyer received a new 5 oz commemorative silver bar with spots on it. The buyer says Bullion Exchanges called it a production defect that doesn't affect value.

The lesson from the first one applies to any dealer: once the carrier records a delivery, the dealer may consider the order closed. Be there to sign, and open the box on camera.

Trustpilot: strong, with invited reviews. Bullion Exchanges has a 4.5 TrustScore from 1,364 reviews. It has claimed its profile, pays for a Trustpilot subscription and invites customers to leave reviews, so a good share of those reviews were asked for. It has replied to 94% of negative reviews, though its replies usually took more than a month. (Trustpilot)

One federal lawsuit, outcome unconfirmed. In Merhi v. Bullion Exchanges, LLC et al., a customer who bought $86,563.20 of gold coins sued Bullion Exchanges and FedEx over a shipment made in October 2022. The case was filed in New York state court in 2023 and moved to federal court in Manhattan (S.D.N.Y., No. 1:23-cv-04577). A September 2024 opinion dealt with whether federal law preempts the claims, a conversion claim, Bullion Exchanges' claims against FedEx and FedEx's limits on its liability. (Justia docket, September 2024 opinion)

Our June review said Bullion Exchanges won summary judgment in February 2025 and was dropped from the case. We haven't found a primary source for that, so we've removed it, and we don't say how the case ended.

So, a scam? No. A scam doesn't stay BBB-accredited with an A+ rating since 2015, answer its complaints and keep its cheapest coins in stock most days. But its thin stock means most listings you see aren't orders you can place, and its terms put a delivered-but-missing package on you.

Can you trust them?

Company. Bullion Exchanges, LLC started in December 2012. Its store is on West 47th Street in Manhattan's Diamond District, and it offers in-store pickup there. The BBB lists Ben Tseytlin as co-owner and Robert Fuks as operations manager. (BBB)

Ownership. No parent company on record. Not a Gold.com subsidiary, and not related to JM Bullion. Details are above.

BBB. Rated A+ and accredited since December 17, 2015. 25 complaints in the last three years, 7 in the last 12 months.

Trustpilot. 4.5 out of 5 across 1,364 reviews. Profile claimed; the company invites reviews and has replied to 94% of negative ones.

Legal. One federal case found, Merhi v. Bullion Exchanges (S.D.N.Y.), over a 2022 shipment. Outcome not confirmed.

Shipping, payment and returns

Bullion Exchanges
PaymentCredit and debit card, PayPal, BitPay, bank wire, eCheck (ACH) through Plaid, paper check
In storePickup at the New York store; cash accepted, with limits
Check and eCheckHeld 5 to 10 business days before the order ships or can be picked up
ReturnsAsk by email within 7 days of receipt; needs prior authorization and approval
Return costsOriginal shipping isn't refunded; you pay return shipping; a 10% restocking fee may apply
Market movesA market-loss fee may apply on bullion; market gains stay with Bullion Exchanges

Source: the business's own statements on its BBB profile, read November 18, 2026. We couldn't open Bullion Exchanges' own site to re-check free-shipping thresholds, carriers, the card surcharge or payment limits, so they aren't in this table.

Every price on this page is Bullion Exchanges' check and wire price. Paying by check or eCheck adds a hold of 5 to 10 business days before your order moves. The terms describe no such hold for a wire, so if you're buying one of the cheap in-stock coins above, wire is the method to ask about first.

Should you buy from Bullion Exchanges?

Find your line:

  • Random-year Gold Eagles: yes, check Bullion Exchanges first. Cheapest on 58 of 65 days at $61.44 over spot, in stock 87.8% of the time. Ten coins cost $613.20 less than at SD Bullion.
  • Random-year Krugerrands: yes. Cheapest on 46 of 48 days at $22.39 over spot, in stock 77.3% of the time.
  • Pre-1933 $20 gold: yes, with JM Bullion as your backup. Cheapest on 72 of 74 days, in stock 72.1% of the time. Five coins cost $172.60 less than at JM.
  • 1 oz gold bars: yes, buy whichever bar is in stock. Cheapest on 72 of 74 days; only 25.6% of bar listings were in stock, but at least one was on 76 of 76 days.
  • Random-year Gold Maples: only when it's in stock. Cheapest on 36 of 38 days, but its Maples were in stock only 18.3% of the time. Otherwise, see our Hero Bullion review.
  • Random-year Gold Buffalos: check SD Bullion too. Bullion Exchanges was cheapest on 33 of 41 days it had one, but it had one on only 41 of 74 days. See our SD Bullion review.
  • Gold Britannias and specific-year coins: no. The Britannia listing was the cheapest on 74 of 77 days and never in stock.
  • Graded coins: browse, don't count on it. 495 graded coins, 3.3% in stock.
  • Silver: we can't say. Our tracking covers Bullion Exchanges' gold only.
  • You want a public parent company behind your dealer: not here. Bullion Exchanges isn't part of Gold.com.
  • Paying by check: expect to wait. Checks and eCheck are held 5 to 10 business days. Pay by wire.

The verdict

Bullion Exchanges is a legitimate New York dealer, with no parent company on record, an A+ BBB rating, a 4.5 TrustScore and a store on West 47th Street.

Its reputation for low prices is earned, on a short list. On random-year Gold Eagles and Krugerrands, Pre-1933 $20 gold and 1 oz bars, it was the cheapest dealer we track on most days, and those listings were usually in stock. Ten Gold Eagles cost $613.20 less than at the cheapest dealer that usually has stock.

Its reputation for thin stock is earned too. Only 4.9% of its listings were in stock over 30 days, the lowest we track. Its Britannias were the cheapest listing almost every day and never buyable. Its Maples were in stock less than a fifth of the time.

So here's how we'd use it. Check Bullion Exchanges first for random-year Gold Eagles, Krugerrands, Pre-1933 $20 gold and 1 oz bars, and buy what's actually in stock. Treat every other low price there as a listing until it says otherwise. Pay by wire, and be home for the signature.

Before you order, check today's prices across every dealer we track. A median over three months tells you who's usually cheapest. Today's price tells you who's cheapest now.

Related: Is JM Bullion legit? · Is SD Bullion legit? · Is Hero Bullion legit? · Is APMEX legit? · Is Money Metals Exchange legit? · How we rate dealers · How much over spot should you pay for gold? · Today's prices: American Gold Eagles · Krugerrands · Pre-1933 gold

FAQ

Does BullionExchanges actually ship at their listed prices?

On a short list, yes. Its random-year Gold Eagle was in stock 87.8% of the time and its Krugerrand 77.3%, at the lowest prices we track. Across the whole catalog, only 4.9% of listings were in stock over 30 days.

Is Bullion Exchanges cheaper than APMEX?

On the gold it keeps in stock, yes. Its medians on random-year Gold Eagles, Krugerrands and Maples, 1 oz bars and Pre-1933 $20 gold were below every dealer that usually has stock. APMEX keeps far more of its catalog in stock.

Is Bullion Exchanges cheaper than JM Bullion?

On the coins it keeps in stock, yes. Five Pre-1933 $20 gold coins, JM's strongest product, cost $172.60 less at the median. But 24.8% of JM's listings were in stock over 30 days, against 4.9% at Bullion Exchanges.

Who owns Bullion Exchanges?

Its BBB profile lists Ben Tseytlin as co-owner and Robert Fuks as operations manager, and no parent company. It isn't a Gold.com subsidiary: Gold.com's filings identify BX Corporation as BullionMax, not Bullion Exchanges.

Not that we can find. Gold.com's fiscal 2025 annual report names Bullion Exchanges as a JM Bullion competitor, and neither recent annual report lists it as a Gold.com business. Our June review said they were sister companies. That was wrong.

Where does Bullion Exchanges ship from?

Its store is on West 47th Street in Manhattan's Diamond District, per its BBB listing, and it offers in-store pickup there. We couldn't open its shipping page to confirm where online orders ship from.

Is Bullion Exchanges BBB accredited?

Yes. It's rated A+ and has been accredited since December 17, 2015. Its BBB file shows 25 complaints in the last three years, 7 of them in the last 12 months. The two newest are marked answered.

Does Bullion Exchanges accept Bitcoin?

Yes, through BitPay, according to the payment terms on its BBB profile. It also takes cards, PayPal, bank wire, eCheck through Plaid and paper checks. Prices on this page are its check and wire price.

How long does Bullion Exchanges take to ship?

We couldn't confirm a processing time. Its payment terms on the BBB profile say check and eCheck payments are held 5 to 10 business days before an order ships or can be picked up. The terms describe no such hold for a wire.

How we measured this

BullionMetric records the listed price and stock status of every tracked product at US online dealers most days. Eleven dealers are tracked: APMEX, BGASC, BullionExchanges, GoldenStateMint, Hero Bullion, JM Bullion, Kitco, Money Metals Exchange, Provident Metals, SD Bullion and SilverGoldBull.

Window. July 13 to October 11, 2026. We recorded Bullion Exchanges on 77 days. No prices were collected for any dealer from September 29 to October 2, because of a data-collection outage. Our tracking of Bullion Exchanges covers 1,518 products, all gold; we don't track its silver.

Day counts. Bullion Exchanges is ranked against every dealer we track, on days its own listing was in stock. Ties count as a win for each tied dealer. The Britannia result is the one listed-price count: it ranks Bullion Exchanges against the dealers that usually have stock using every listing, in stock or not.

Medians, spot and prices.

  • Dollar medians use every in-stock observation in the window.
  • Premiums are measured against an independent reference spot price.
  • Prices are each dealer's check and wire price.
  • Stock status is what each dealer's own site shows.
  • The 30-day in-stock rates cover September 12 to October 11.

What's included. Listings with premiums between 0% and 300%. Products: 1 oz coins, 1 oz gold bars and Pre-1933 $20 gold double eagles.

What's excluded. Graded and certified coins, proofs and special finishes, privy and limited editions, listings marked off-quality or damaged, gift packaging, and multi-coin tubes, rolls and boxes.

Random year and specific year. "Random year" means listings sold as random year, plus listings that state no year. Specific-year listings are compared separately.

"Dealers that usually have stock." Our other reviews rank dealers only against APMEX, BGASC, Hero Bullion, JM Bullion, Money Metals Exchange, Provident Metals and SD Bullion. Bullion Exchanges is left out of that group because fewer than one in ten of its listings were in stock. GoldenStateMint is left out of it because its stock signal is unverified. The dollar comparisons on this page use the cheapest dealer in that group.

A check on the day count. We also ranked Bullion Exchanges against only the dealers that usually have stock, dropping the days we captured only part of its gold catalog, and against a stricter set of days when every dealer was fully tracked. On random-year Gold Eagles, Krugerrands, 1 oz bars and Pre-1933 $20 gold, it was still the usual winner. On the stricter days, random-year Gold Maples were a tie with Hero Bullion.

What changed since June. Our first review, published in June 2026, measured premiums against each dealer's own displayed spot, used whole product categories rather than random-year and specific-year coins, and mixed in-stock and listed results. Under that method, Krugerrands looked like Bullion Exchanges' only buyable win, and Gold Eagles looked like a loss. This version replaces those findings. It also withdraws the June review's ownership claim and its account of the Merhi case. Full methodology →

Last updated: November 18, 2026. Premium data through October 11, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Does BullionExchanges actually ship at their listed prices?

On a short list, yes. Its random-year Gold Eagle was in stock 87.8% of the time and its Krugerrand 77.3%, at the lowest prices we track. Across the whole catalog, only 4.9% of listings were in stock over 30 days.

Is Bullion Exchanges cheaper than APMEX?

On the gold it keeps in stock, yes. Its medians on random-year Gold Eagles, Krugerrands and Maples, 1 oz bars and Pre-1933 $20 gold were below every dealer that usually has stock. APMEX keeps far more of its catalog in stock.

Is Bullion Exchanges cheaper than JM Bullion?

On the coins it keeps in stock, yes. Five Pre-1933 $20 gold coins, JM's strongest product, cost $172.60 less at the median. But 24.8% of JM's listings were in stock over 30 days, against 4.9% at Bullion Exchanges.

Who owns Bullion Exchanges?

Its BBB profile lists Ben Tseytlin as co-owner and Robert Fuks as operations manager, and no parent company. It isn't a Gold.com subsidiary: Gold.com's filings identify BX Corporation as BullionMax, not Bullion Exchanges.

Is Bullion Exchanges related to JM Bullion?

Not that we can find. Gold.com's fiscal 2025 annual report names Bullion Exchanges as a JM Bullion competitor, and neither recent annual report lists it as a Gold.com business. Our June review said they were sister companies. That was wrong.

Where does Bullion Exchanges ship from?

Its store is on West 47th Street in Manhattan's Diamond District, per its BBB listing, and it offers in-store pickup there. We couldn't open its shipping page to confirm where online orders ship from.

Is Bullion Exchanges BBB accredited?

Yes. It's rated A+ and has been accredited since December 17, 2015. Its BBB file shows 25 complaints in the last three years, 7 of them in the last 12 months. The two newest are marked answered.

Does Bullion Exchanges accept Bitcoin?

Yes, through BitPay, according to the payment terms on its BBB profile. It also takes cards, PayPal, bank wire, eCheck through Plaid and paper checks. Prices on this page are its check and wire price.

How long does Bullion Exchanges take to ship?

We couldn't confirm a processing time. Its payment terms on the BBB profile say check and eCheck payments are held 5 to 10 business days before an order ships or can be picked up. The terms describe no such hold for a wire.

Compare prices by coin: Gold Eagle prices and premiums · Krugerrand prices and premiums · Pre-1933 gold coin prices