Updated November 18, 2026. We rewrote this review with our tracking from July 13 to October 11, 2026. Premiums are now measured against an independent reference spot price, and SD Bullion is ranked only against dealers that usually have stock. Two conclusions moved:
- The June version said SD was never the cheapest on Gold Eagles. Under the current method it was the cheapest of those dealers on every day we compared specific-year Gold Eagles, and on most days for random-year ones.
- The June version called SD the cheapest on Krugerrands and Pre-1933 gold, and said it beat APMEX on nearly every comparable day. Money Metals Exchange and JM Bullion were usually cheaper on Krugerrands and Pre-1933 gold, and on identical products SD and APMEX were close to even.
It also called the Vickery lawsuit a class action. The docket pages we read don't describe it that way. Details are in How we measured this and How we track premiums.
The short answer
Yes, SD Bullion is a legitimate online bullion dealer: it has sold bullion since 2012, holds an A+ BBB rating as an accredited business, and has a 4.1 TrustScore on Trustpilot from 3,158 reviews. Among dealers that usually have stock, it was the cheapest on Gold Eagles, on all 76 of 76 days for specific-year coins and 46 of 79 days for random-year coins, at a median of $122.76 over spot. It was also the cheapest on random-year Gold Buffalos on 59 of 79 days. It was not cheap on Silver Eagles, Gold Maple Leafs or Krugerrands, and two dealers that rarely have stock, which we leave out of the rankings, posted lower Gold Eagle prices. SD is also a defendant in a federal lawsuit in California that's still open.
Here's the evidence.
The "lowest prices" claim, tested
SD's shipping page still says it has offered the lowest prices in the industry, guaranteed, since 2012. That's a claim our data can check, product by product.
It holds on Gold Eagles, random-year Gold Buffalos and Gold Philharmonics, and specific-year Silver Krugerrands. It doesn't hold on Silver Eagles, Gold Maple Leafs, Krugerrands or Pre-1933 gold, where other dealers were usually cheaper, sometimes by a lot. And it gets weaker on Gold Eagles once you add the dealers that rarely have stock.
So the claim is true on a short list of gold coins and false on most of the rest. Use SD product by product, not as a default.
Where SD Bullion is the cheapest
Here's how SD ranked against the dealers that usually have stock:
| Product (1 oz unless noted) | Days compared | SD cheapest | SD median over spot | Usually cheapest |
|---|
| Gold Eagle, specific year | 76 | 76 | $223.56 (5.28%) | SD Bullion |
| Gold Buffalo, random year | 79 | 59 | $163.98 (3.83%) | SD Bullion |
| Gold Eagle, random year | 79 | 46 | $122.76 (2.84%) | SD Bullion |
| Gold Philharmonic, random year | 77 | 41 | $95.45 (2.25%) | SD Bullion |
| Pre-1933 gold | 64 | 9 | $84.20 | JM Bullion, $79.42 |
| Krugerrand, random year | 78 | 3 | $100.42 | Money Metals, $72.45 |
| Silver Eagle, random year | 44 | 0 | $12.60 (19.46%) | Not SD |
"Cheapest" means SD's median in-stock premium that day was the lowest among dealers that usually have stock, on days at least three of them had the product in stock. Medians are per coin, at SD's check and wire price.
Gold Eagles: SD's clear win. On specific-year Gold Eagles, SD was cheapest on 76 of 76 days. That isn't just SD stocking more of the cheaper recent years: on coins dated before 2024 alone, it was still cheapest on 76 of 76 days, at a median of $228.27 over spot. On random-year Gold Eagles, it was cheapest on 46 of 79 days.
Random-year Gold Buffalos: the other clear win. Cheapest on 59 of 79 days, at $163.98 over spot.
Random-year Gold Philharmonics: a narrow lead. SD had the lowest median, $95.45, and was cheapest on 41 of 77 days. On a stricter day count, and with every dealer included, it loses that lead. Treat it as close.
Specific-year Silver Krugerrands. A small market, but SD was cheapest on all 36 of 36 days it had them in stock, at $6.19 an ounce over spot. That held even with every dealer included.
The caveat on Gold Eagles. Those results are among dealers that usually have stock. Put back the two we leave out and they take most Gold Eagle days: BullionExchanges was cheapest on 58 of 79 days for random-year coins, and GoldenStateMint (stock unverified) on 42 of 78 days for specific-year coins. SD's wins fall to 6 and 13. We keep both out of the rankings because fewer than one in ten of BullionExchanges' listings were in stock over the last month of the window, and GoldenStateMint's stock signal is unverified. If either one quotes you a lower Gold Eagle price, check that you can actually buy it.
Where SD Bullion is not the cheapest
- Silver Eagles. On random-year Silver Eagles, SD was cheapest on 0 of 44 days, at a median of $12.60 an ounce over spot (19.46%). On specific-year Silver Eagles, its median was $30.38 an ounce, the highest of 7 dealers. Hero Bullion's was $10.38.
- Gold Maple Leafs. A random-year Gold Maple cost $171.45 over spot at SD against $82.07 at Hero Bullion: $89.38 more a coin.
- Krugerrands. On random-year Krugerrands SD was cheapest on 3 of 78 days. Its median was $100.42 a coin. Money Metals Exchange's was $72.45.
- Pre-1933 gold. Close, but JM Bullion usually won. SD was cheapest on 9 of 64 days, at $84.20 a coin against JM's $79.42.
- Silver bars. SD never won a day on 10 oz silver bars, and its median was the highest of the dealers that usually have stock. Hero Bullion was the usual winner.
The weak spot is SD's list of specific-year Gold Eagles: most of those listings were out of stock on a given day. But the Gold Eagles that enter our rankings were in stock on every day we fully tracked SD's gold. If you want a particular back year, expect to look around. If you want a Gold Eagle, SD has had one.
Catalog and graded coins
We track 380 SD products: 246 gold, 132 silver and 2 other. That's the smallest gold and silver catalog among the dealers that usually have stock; APMEX and JM Bullion each list several times as many. 50 of SD's products are graded coins.
If you're buying for the slab, SD isn't the place. Use it for bullion, and see our APMEX review for graded depth.
SD Bullion vs APMEX and JM Bullion
Two of the most common searches about SD are head-to-heads. We compared the same product on the same day, with both dealers in stock.
vs APMEX: close to even. SD was cheaper on 1,857 of 3,665 comparisons, 50.7%. The June version of this review said SD was cheaper on nearly every comparable day. That came from an older method and doesn't hold. APMEX has a far bigger catalog and many more graded coins. See our APMEX review.
vs JM Bullion: SD usually wins. SD was cheaper on 826 of 1,301 comparisons, 63.5%. On Gold Eagles it was cheaper on 84.7% of 320 pairs; the June version had that the other way round. Ten random-year Gold Buffalos cost $1,474 less at SD. See our JM Bullion review.
Reputation and trust signals
Company. SD's about page names Tyler Wall as Founder and President and says the company has operated since 2012. The BBB profile shows the business started in 2011, with 15 years in business, and lists Dr. Tyler Wall as President and Owner and Chase Turner as CEO. The BBB lists SD Bullion, Inc. in Fort Worth, Texas. (About SD Bullion, BBB)
Scale. SD's about page says it has handled more than 2,000,000 orders for more than 600,000 customers, more than $6 billion in transactions, and made the Inc. 5000 six times. Those are the company's own figures.
BBB. Rated A+ and accredited since April 22, 2014. We didn't capture the complaint count on this update, so we don't print one.
Trustpilot. A TrustScore of 4.1 ("Great") from 3,158 reviews. SD claimed the profile in 2016. Trustpilot shows no recent history of SD inviting customers to leave reviews, and SD replied to 22% of negative reviews. (Trustpilot)
Marketing. The "lowest prices, guaranteed, since 2012" line on SD's shipping page holds on Gold Eagles and Buffalos and fails on Maples, Krugerrands, Pre-1933 gold, Silver Eagles and silver bars.
The lawsuit
Vickery v. SD Bullion, Inc. et al., No. 3:25-cv-01915, is in federal court in the Southern District of California. It was filed on July 28, 2025. The docket lists the cause as deceptive trade practices, the nature of suit as a contract claim, and a jury demand by the plaintiff. Smart Silver Stacker, Silver Dragons, Yankee Stacking and Silver Seeker are also named as defendants. On January 20, 2026, the court granted in part and denied in part SD Bullion's motion to dismiss. The case is still open, with recent filings on the docket. (CourtListener, Justia)
Our June review called this a class action. The docket pages we read don't describe it as one, so we've corrected that. Other cases naming SD appear in search results, but we haven't confirmed them on a docket, so we don't list them here. That doesn't mean Vickery is the only one.
Shipping, payment and returns
| SD Bullion |
|---|
| Free shipping | Orders $199+ |
| Processing | Ships within 1–3 business days after payment clears, under normal conditions |
| Carrier | UPS named on the shipping page |
| e-check | The 4% discount; up to $10,000 per order |
| Bank wire | Not available under $2,500; the only method above $20,000 |
| Personal or cashier's check | Up to $20,000 |
| Bitcoin (BitPay) | Up to $250,000 |
| Credit or debit card | Up to $5,000; Visa, Mastercard, Discover; not eligible for the 4% discount |
| PayPal | Up to $500; not eligible for the 4% discount |
| Returns | 3 business days to report a defect or fulfillment error; you pay return shipping |
| Restocking fee | 5% or $35, whichever is higher, plus any market-loss fee |
| Orders | Binding once placed |
Sources: Shipping, Payment and pricing, Returns and refunds.
Every SD price on this page is the check and wire price. Pay by card or PayPal and you lose the 4% discount, which on a gold coin is bigger than SD's lead over Hero Bullion on random-year Gold Eagles. If you buy from SD, pay by e-check or wire.
Who should buy from SD Bullion
- Gold Eagles: yes, SD first. Cheapest among dealers that usually have stock on 76 of 76 days for specific-year coins and 46 of 79 for random-year coins. If BullionExchanges or GoldenStateMint (stock unverified) shows a lower price, confirm you can buy it.
- Random-year Gold Buffalos: yes. Cheapest on 59 of 79 days, and $1,474 less than JM Bullion on ten coins.
- Random-year Gold Philharmonics: often. Lowest median at $95.45, but a narrow lead. Compare on the day.
- Specific-year Silver Krugerrands: yes. Cheapest on all 36 days SD had them in stock.
- Pre-1933 gold: compare with JM Bullion. JM's median was $79.42 to SD's $84.20.
- Random-year Krugerrands: no. Check Money Metals Exchange first.
- Gold Maple Leafs: no. Hero Bullion was $89.38 a coin cheaper. See our Hero Bullion review.
- Silver Eagles and silver bars: no. SD won 0 of 44 days on random-year Silver Eagles and had the highest specific-year Silver Eagle median of 7 dealers.
- Graded coins: limited fit. 50 graded products. Use APMEX for depth.
- Paying by card: weaker fit. The 4% discount you give up is bigger than most of SD's leads.
The verdict
SD Bullion is legit: an A+ BBB rating, 15 years in business on its BBB file, a 4.1 Trustpilot score, and one open federal lawsuit you should know about.
On price, it's the Gold Eagle and Buffalo dealer among those that usually have stock, and the gap to JM Bullion on those coins is large. It isn't the cheapest on Silver Eagles, Gold Maples, Krugerrands or silver bars. Its "lowest prices, guaranteed" line is true on a short list of gold coins and not much else.
So here's how we'd use it. Buy Gold Eagles, random-year Buffalos and Philharmonics here. Check Money Metals Exchange on Krugerrands, Hero Bullion on Maples and silver, and JM Bullion on Pre-1933 gold. Pay by e-check or wire.
Before you order, check today's prices across every dealer we track. A median over the window tells you who's usually cheapest. Today's price tells you who's cheapest now.
Related: Is JM Bullion legit? · Is APMEX legit? · Is Hero Bullion legit? · Is Money Metals Exchange legit? · Is Bullion Exchanges legit? · Is Golden State Mint legit? · How we rate dealers · How much over spot should you pay for gold? · How much over spot for silver?
FAQ
Is SD Bullion cheaper than APMEX?
Close to even. On the same product on the same day, with both in stock, SD was cheaper on 1,857 of 3,665 comparisons (50.7%) from July to October 2026. APMEX has a far larger catalog and many more graded coins.
Is SD Bullion cheaper than JM Bullion?
Usually. On the same product on the same day, SD was cheaper than JM Bullion on 826 of 1,301 comparisons (63.5%), and on 84.7% of 320 pairs for Gold Eagles. Ten random-year Gold Buffalos cost $1,474 less at SD.
Who owns SD Bullion?
The BBB lists Dr. Tyler Wall as President and Owner and Chase Turner as CEO. SD's about page names Wall as Founder and President and says the company has operated since 2012. The BBB lists it in Fort Worth, Texas.
Where does SD Bullion ship from?
The SD pages we checked don't give a warehouse address, and the BBB lists the company in Fort Worth, Texas. SD says orders ship within 1–3 business days after payment clears, and its shipping page names UPS.
Is SD Bullion facing a lawsuit?
Yes. Vickery v. SD Bullion, Inc. et al., No. 3:25-cv-01915, was filed in federal court in the Southern District of California on July 28, 2025. On January 20, 2026 the court granted in part and denied in part SD's motion to dismiss. It is still open.
Does SD Bullion accept Bitcoin?
Yes, through BitPay, on orders up to $250,000. For the lowest price, SD's payment page names e-check, which gets a 4% discount on orders up to $10,000. Cards are capped at $5,000 and PayPal at $500.
How long does SD Bullion take to ship?
SD says orders ship within 1–3 business days after payment clears, under normal conditions. Carrier transit time comes on top of that. Shipping is free on orders of $199+.
Does SD Bullion report to the IRS?
Not when you buy; a purchase isn't a reportable event. When you sell certain bullion back in reportable quantities, dealers file Form 1099-B. Gold and Silver Eagles aren't on that list.
How we measured this
BullionMetric records the listed price and stock status of every tracked product at US online dealers most days. Eleven dealers are tracked: APMEX, BGASC, BullionExchanges, GoldenStateMint, Hero Bullion, JM Bullion, Kitco, Money Metals Exchange, Provident Metals, SD Bullion and SilverGoldBull.
Window. July 13 to October 11, 2026. We recorded SD on 77 days. No prices were collected for any dealer from September 29 to October 2, because of a data-collection outage. SD's counts use only the days we tracked its full catalog for that metal.
Day counts. Rankings count every day at least three dealers that usually have stock had the product in stock. Gold uses the full window. Silver starts in late August, when we first fully tracked Hero Bullion's silver. Every SD day in that silver window was fully tracked. Ties count as a win for each tied dealer.
Medians, spot and prices.
- Dollar medians use every in-stock observation in the window.
- Premiums are measured against an independent reference spot price.
- Prices are each dealer's check and wire price.
- Stock status is what each dealer's own site shows.
- The in-stock rates cover September 12 to October 11.
What's included. In-stock listings only, with premiums between 0% and 300%. Products: 1 oz coins, 1 oz gold bars, 10 oz and 100 oz silver bars, and Pre-1933 gold double eagles.
What's excluded. Graded and certified coins, proofs and special finishes, privy and limited editions, listings marked off-quality or damaged, gift packaging, and multi-coin tubes, rolls and boxes.
Random year and specific year. "Random year" means listings sold as random year. For coins other than Silver Eagles, it also includes listings that state no year. Specific-year listings are compared separately.
"Dealers that usually have stock." APMEX, BGASC, Hero Bullion, JM Bullion, Money Metals Exchange, Provident Metals and SD Bullion, plus Kitco for silver. GoldenStateMint is left out because its stock signal is unverified. BullionExchanges and SilverGoldBull are left out because fewer than one in ten of their listings were in stock.
A check on the day count. On a stricter basis that uses only the days every dealer was fully tracked, SD still won every specific-year Gold Eagle day and most random-year Gold Eagle and Buffalo days. On random-year Philharmonics it lost the lead to Hero Bullion by a single day, and it won no random-year Krugerrand days.
What changed since June. Our first review, published June 25, 2026, used data through June 25. It measured premiums against each dealer's own displayed spot, used whole product categories rather than random-year and specific-year coins, and counted every dealer as a competitor, including GoldenStateMint and BullionExchanges. Under that method, SD looked like it never won on Gold Eagles and always won on Krugerrands, Philharmonics and Pre-1933 gold. This version replaces those findings. Full methodology →
Last updated: November 18, 2026. Premium data through October 11, 2026.