About this review. BullionMetric records the price and stock status of every listing at the major US online bullion dealers, most days of the week. This review uses our tracking from July 13 to October 11, 2026, measured against an independent reference spot price rather than each dealer's own displayed spot. Company and policy facts come from Money Metals' own pages and the sources linked in each section. How we track premiums →
Correction. We rewrote this review on October 24, 2026. The June version used an older method that measured each dealer against its own displayed spot price, counted Golden State Mint as a competitor, and counted a "win" even when no other dealer stocked the product. Under our current method, three of its findings were wrong. Money Metals is the cheapest dealer that usually has stock on random-year Krugerrands; we had said it never was. Its "100% of days" wins on Walking Liberty rounds, Perth Mint coins, America the Beautiful 5 oz coins and MapleGrams were contests it ran alone, so we've removed them. And it was close to the cheapest on random-year Silver Eagles, not out of the running. Details are in How we measured this.
The short answer
Yes, Money Metals Exchange is a legitimate online bullion dealer. It has been in business since 2010, is based in Eagle, Idaho, and holds an A+ BBB rating as an accredited business. Trustpilot reviewers rate it 4.5 out of 5 across 478 reviews.
On price, it has one clear win and one near-win. It was the cheapest dealer that usually has stock on random-year Krugerrands on 40 of 68 days. On random-year Silver Eagles it ran neck and neck with Kitco. It was never the cheapest on Gold Eagles or Gold Buffalos, where its median was the highest we track. And it kept more of its catalog in stock than any other full-catalog dealer: 87.5% of listings, against 44.5% at the next best.
Here's the evidence, including the parts that cost you money.
The dealer that's always in stock
Start with what Money Metals does better than anyone we track: it has the coin.
Over the last 30 days, 87.5% of its gold and silver listings were in stock. The next-best full-catalog dealer, BGASC, managed 44.5%. APMEX was at 27.8%.
| Dealer | Gold and silver listings in stock, last 30 days |
|---|
| BullionExchanges | 4.9% |
| SilverGoldBull | 9.9% |
| Provident Metals | 20.5% |
| Hero Bullion | 21.4% |
| JM Bullion | 24.8% |
| APMEX | 27.8% |
| SD Bullion | 43.6% |
| BGASC | 44.5% |
| Money Metals Exchange | 87.5% |
| Kitco | 100%† |
| GoldenStateMint | unverified* |
*GoldenStateMint is a private mint with a narrow retail catalog. Our tracking records its listings as in stock, but we haven't verified that its stock signal reflects real availability, so we don't report a rate for it.
†Kitco has 23 silver listings in our tracking and no gold, so its rate rests on a small catalog.
"Cheapest" means Money Metals' median in-stock premium that day was the lowest among dealers that usually have stock, on days at least three of them had the product. Gold uses every day in the window. Silver starts August 22, the first day we fully tracked Hero Bullion's silver.
Three results stand out.
Random-year Krugerrands: Money Metals first. Cheapest on 40 of the 68 days it had them, second on 20 more. Its median was $72.45 over spot, the lowest of any dealer that usually has stock. Hero Bullion was next at $79.78. And its single random-year Krugerrand listing was in stock every day we tracked it.
Random-year Silver Eagles: a two-horse race with Kitco. Across the full window, Money Metals had the lowest median of any dealer that usually has stock: $11.02 over spot, against Kitco's $11.40. Since late August, Kitco has edged ahead. It was cheapest on 21 of the 32 days it had stock, Money Metals on 9 of 41. But Money Metals was first or second on 31 of those 41 days, and it had the coin in stock on more of them.
One warning. Money Metals also lists Silver Eagles in a congratulations capsule ($21.05 over spot) and in a wooden display box ($48.20). They're gifts, not bullion buys. If you're stacking, pick the plain listing marked "random year."
Silver bars and rounds: the reliable runner-up. Money Metals was rarely first on silver, because Hero Bullion was cheaper almost every day. But it was second on 10 oz bars 42 of 43 days, and second on rounds 38 of 42.
What the wins are worth
| Order | Money Metals, median over spot | Next dealer | Others | Money Metals saves you |
|---|
| Ten random-year Krugerrands | $72.45/coin | Hero Bullion, $79.78 | SD Bullion $100.42, JM Bullion $132.86, APMEX $155.63 | $73 vs Hero, $832 vs APMEX |
| 100 random-year Silver Eagles | $11.57/oz since Aug 22 | Kitco, $11.25 | SD Bullion $12.61, APMEX $14.26, Provident $14.32 | Kitco $32 cheaper; Money Metals $269 cheaper than APMEX |
Medians at the check and wire price. The Silver Eagle row uses August 22 onward, the same days as the table above.
Most of the time, the gap between Money Metals and the dealer just behind it is small. The gap to APMEX and JM Bullion is not.
Niche silver, honestly counted
Our June review said Money Metals won 100% of days on several niche coins. Most of those were contests it ran alone. Under our current rule that a day counts only when three dealers that usually have stock had the product, two niche wins hold up:
- Silver Koalas: cheapest on 43 of 45 days, against four other dealers.
- Silver Tudor Beasts: cheapest on all 10 days that three dealers had them. That's a small sample.
Australian Lunar coins (16 of 64 days) and Silver Libertads (0 of 30) were not wins.
Here's the other side, in dollars:
| Order | Money Metals, median over spot | Cheapest dealer that usually has stock | Money Metals costs you more |
|---|
| Ten random-year Gold Buffalos | $320.75/coin | SD Bullion, $163.98 | $1,568 |
| Ten random-year Gold Eagles | $232.15/coin | SD Bullion, $122.76 | $1,094 |
| 100 specific-year Silver Eagles | $18.88/oz | Hero Bullion, $10.38 | $850 |
| Ten random-year Gold Maples | $156.25/coin | Hero Bullion, $82.07 | $742 |
| Ten specific-year Gold Eagles | $289.38/coin | SD Bullion, $223.56 | $658 |
| Ten random-year Gold Philharmonics | $154.07/coin | SD Bullion, $95.45 | $586 |
| Ten 1 oz gold bars | $156.62/bar | Hero Bullion, $109.53 | $471 |
| 100 random-year Silver Britannias | $9.90/oz | Hero Bullion, $5.70 | $420 |
| 100 random-year Silver Maples | $9.62/oz | Hero Bullion, $6.50 | $312 |
| Ten 10 oz silver bars (100 oz) | $6.68/oz | Hero Bullion, $4.95 | $173 |
| 100 oz of junk silver | $3.77/oz | SD Bullion, $2.23 | $154 |
| 100 silver rounds | $6.76/oz | Hero Bullion, $5.41 | $135 |
Gold Eagles are the clearest miss. Money Metals was never the cheapest on a random-year or specific-year Gold Eagle on any day we tracked. Its random-year median was the highest of any dealer that usually has stock. Ten coins would have cost about $1,094 more than at SD Bullion. Random-year Gold Buffalos were the same story: the highest median we track, and $157 a coin over SD Bullion's.
Specific-year gold is mixed. On specific-year Gold Maples, Money Metals was second to BGASC: $161.75 over spot against $155.56, cheapest on 26 of 67 days. On the 33 days every dealer in the comparison was fully tracked, though, BGASC won 28 of those days and Money Metals 5. If you want a dated Maple, check both.
Same coin, same day
Comparing medians across a dealer's whole range can blur things, so we also lined up the same product on the same day, both in stock:
| Against | Comparisons | Money Metals cheaper | Money Metals more expensive |
|---|
| APMEX | 581 | 79% | 21% |
| SD Bullion | 993 | 59% | 41% |
| JM Bullion | 1,172 | 46% | 54% |
| Provident Metals | 2,340 | 29% | 71% |
| Hero Bullion | 1,401 | 8% | 92% |
Money Metals usually beats APMEX on the same product. Hero Bullion and Provident Metals usually beat Money Metals.
The complaints, addressed
The searches that bring people here are "is Money Metals legit" and "Money Metals complaints." The BBB complaints file and several Reddit threads rank for both. Here's what they say.
The BBB file has 45 complaints over three years, 19 of them in the last 12 months. That's up from 34 and 18 when we first read the file in June. In June, the recurring themes were disputes over price-lock and cancellation terms, lost packages, cancelled orders, and how disputes were handled. (BBB complaints)
The newest complaint on the file, from August 24, 2026, is worth reading if you hold an account. The customer says someone impersonated them by email and asked Money Metals to change the bank account on file. The impostor then requested a same-day ACH transfer of a large sum to the new account. The customer says they got no phone call or text confirming the change. BBB marks the complaint as answered. We don't know the outcome or the details beyond what's on the file.
The lesson applies to any dealer that pays you out: turn on every account security option, and ask how the dealer verifies a change of bank details before you sell back.
Trustpilot is polarized. Money Metals scores 4.5 out of 5 across 478 reviews, but the stars are split: 70% five-star and 24% one-star, with almost nothing between. 344 of those reviews arrived in the last 12 months, and Trustpilot says Money Metals hasn't asked customers for reviews, so they're unprompted. The profile is unclaimed. (Trustpilot) We didn't find a Shopper Approved profile for Money Metals.
Reddit is mostly positive, with one recurring gripe. In an r/Silverbugs thread titled "Have any of you guys bought from Money Metals?" (about four years old):
- One buyer who'd bought and sold back to them called the customer service solid and said it was easy to reach a person.
- The same buyer said prices "tend to be a bit higher than some of the others," that the buyback prices were good, and that the newsletter's scare-tactic marketing went straight in the bin.
- Another ordered with no issues and found "decent not-so-common stuff at competitive prices."
- A third summed it up: they buy from Money Metals only when it has the best price, but when they do, they have no problems. (Reddit)
That's consistent with our data. Money Metals is sometimes the best price, often near it, and rarely out of stock. Expect marketing emails.
So, a scam? No. A scam doesn't stay BBB-accredited for 15 years, publish its legal terms, answer its complaints and keep 87% of its catalog in stock. But the complaint count has grown, and the August account-takeover complaint is a reminder to lock down your account.
Can you trust them?
Company. Money Metals Exchange, LLC is based in Eagle, Idaho. Its BBB file says the business started on May 12, 2010 and was incorporated as an LLC on August 1, 2010. It has 95 employees. The file lists Stefan Gleason as president, Clint Siegner and Mike Gleason as owners, and Money Metals Depository as a related business. Besides selling bullion, it buys metal back, and it offers storage and loans secured by metal. (BBB)
BBB. Rated A+ and accredited since March 30, 2011. 45 complaints in the last three years, 19 in the last 12 months.
Trustpilot. 4.5 out of 5 across 478 reviews; 70% five-star, 24% one-star; unclaimed.
Legal. In March 2025, Money Metals and three Kentucky residents sued Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear in Boone Circuit Court, seeking refunds of sales tax collected on bullion purchases. Money Metals was a plaintiff, not a defendant. The suit was filed the same day Kentucky's legislature overrode a veto of House Bill 2, which created the refund claim. We haven't found a final ruling. (Sound Money Defense League announcement, Kentucky Acts 2025, HB 2) Our June review said the case "resolved in favor of the plaintiffs." We couldn't find a source for that, so we've removed it. In web searches as of October 22, 2026, we found no attorney-general actions, consent decrees or consumer class-action settlements naming Money Metals.
Marketing. Money Metals' homepage leads with "Below Spot Silver Deals," free shipping on orders over $199, "Over $7 Billion In Trusted Transactions" and "Best Overall Rated #1 by Investopedia." Its FAQ says the premiums on its silver rounds are "very low." In our data they're the second-lowest of any dealer that usually has stock, behind Hero Bullion. We don't track individual promotional deals. If a below-spot offer fits what you're buying, it can beat every median on this page. (Money Metals, FAQ)
Shipping, payment and returns
| Money Metals Exchange |
|---|
| Free shipping | Orders of $199 or more |
| Ships | Generally within 3 business days of cleared payment |
| Payment | Check, eCheck (ACH), bank wire, money order, card, PayPal, Bitcoin and other crypto |
| Card, PayPal, crypto | A "modest transaction fee" on top of the check and wire price |
| Check and ACH | Ship after payment clears |
| Cancellations | Orders can't be cancelled once placed |
| Returns | Notify within 3 days of receipt; refund or replacement at Money Metals' discretion; 5% restocking fee; original shipping not refunded |
| Lost packages | Report within 7 days of the last tracking scan, or within 2 business days of a tracked delivery; replacement at Money Metals' discretion |
| Monthly program | Automatic monthly purchases that Money Metals says carry lower premiums than its regular prices |
Sources: How to buy, Legal disclosures, Monthly program.
Two lines in that table matter more than the rest.
First, every price on this page is the check and wire price. Pay by card, PayPal or crypto and you pay a fee on top. On a Krugerrand, Money Metals' median lead over Hero Bullion was about $7 a coin. On a coin worth thousands of dollars, even a small percentage fee is many times that.
Second, the order is final once you place it, and you have three days after delivery to raise a problem. Check the box the day it arrives.
Find your line:
- Random-year Krugerrands: yes, Money Metals first. Cheapest on 40 of 68 days, $72.45 over spot, in stock every day.
- Random-year Silver Eagles: yes, check Money Metals and Kitco side by side. Over the full window Money Metals' median was $11.02, the lowest of any dealer that usually has stock, against Kitco's $11.40. Since late August, Kitco has usually been a little cheaper. Buy the plain random-year listing, not the gift packaging.
- You need it in stock today: yes. 87.5% of its listings were in stock, double the next-best full-catalog dealer.
- Silver bars, rounds and junk silver: a strong backup. Usually second, behind Hero Bullion. See our Hero Bullion review.
- Specific-year Gold Maples: check BGASC first. Money Metals was second. See our BGASC review.
- Choosing between Money Metals and APMEX: Money Metals, usually. On the same product, same day, it was cheaper 79% of the time. See our APMEX review.
- Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos: no. Never the cheapest, and the highest median we track. SD Bullion was about $109 a coin cheaper on random-year Gold Eagles. See our SD Bullion review.
- Random-year Gold Maples and 1 oz gold bars: no. Hero Bullion was cheaper.
- Specific-year Silver Eagles: no. Hero Bullion's dated Eagles ran about $8.50 an ounce less.
- Graded coins: limited. We track 18 graded products at Money Metals and 2,690 at APMEX.
- Paying by card: think twice. The card fee eats the small leads Money Metals has.
The verdict
Money Metals Exchange is a legitimate, 16-year-old dealer with an A+ BBB rating and the best stock record of any full-catalog dealer we track.
On price, it's a specialist with a solid middle. It was the cheapest on random-year Krugerrands and co-cheapest with Kitco on random-year Silver Eagles. It was the steady runner-up on silver bars and rounds, and usually cheaper than APMEX on the same product. On Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos, it was the most expensive dealer that usually has stock, more than $100 a coin above the cheapest.
The limits: orders are final once placed, the card fee erases its small leads, the complaint count has grown, and you'll be on the marketing list.
So here's how we'd use it. Buy random-year Krugerrands here. Check it against Kitco for random-year Silver Eagles. Use it when another dealer is out of stock. Buy your Gold Eagles and Buffalos somewhere else. Pay by check or wire.
Before you order, check today's prices across every dealer we track. A 90-day median tells you who's usually cheapest. Today's price tells you who's cheapest now.
Related: Is Hero Bullion legit? · Is SD Bullion legit? · Is BGASC legit? · Is Provident Metals legit? · Is APMEX legit? · Is JM Bullion legit? · Is Bullion Exchanges legit? · How we rate dealers · How much over spot should you pay for silver? · How much over spot for gold? · Where is the cheapest place to buy silver? · Today's prices: Krugerrands · American Silver Eagles · Junk silver
How we measured this
BullionMetric records the listed price and stock status of every tracked product at US online dealers most days. Eleven dealers are tracked: APMEX, BGASC, BullionExchanges, GoldenStateMint, Hero Bullion, JM Bullion, Kitco, Money Metals Exchange, Provident Metals, SD Bullion and SilverGoldBull.
Window. The window is July 13 to October 11, 2026. No prices were collected for any dealer from September 29 to October 2 because of a data-collection outage. We recorded Money Metals on 76 days. We captured only part of its catalog on August 3 (no gold) and August 13 to 17 and 19. It was fully tracked on 68 days for gold and 70 for silver, and those are the days used for the stock-availability counts.
Day counts. Rankings count every day at least three dealers that usually have stock had the product in stock. Gold uses the full window. Silver starts August 22, because Hero Bullion's silver wasn't fully tracked before then. These are the same rules our Hero Bullion review and dealer ratings use.
Medians and spot. Dollar medians use every in-stock observation in the window. The Silver Eagle comparisons also show August 22 onward. Premiums are measured against an independent reference spot price, the midpoint of each day's price range. Prices are each dealer's check and wire price. Stock status is what each dealer's own site shows. The 30-day in-stock rate covers September 12 to October 11.
Included and excluded. Included: in-stock listings only, premiums between 0% and 300%, 1 oz coins weighing 0.95–1.05 troy oz, 1 oz gold bars, and 10 oz silver bars. Excluded: graded and certified coins, proofs and special finishes, privy and limited editions, listings marked off-quality or damaged, gift packaging (including capsules and display boxes), and multi-coin tubes, rolls and boxes. "Random year" means listings sold as random year. Listings for a specific year are compared separately. Silver Eagle listings that state no year aren't counted as random year. We don't track Money Metals' 100 oz silver bars, Gold Britannias or Pre-1933 gold coins in our comparison groups, so none of them is compared here.
"Dealers that usually have stock." This means more than 20% of gold and silver listings in stock over the last 30 days: APMEX, BGASC, Hero Bullion, JM Bullion, Money Metals, Provident Metals and SD Bullion, plus Kitco for silver. GoldenStateMint is excluded because its stock signal is unverified. BullionExchanges and SilverGoldBull are excluded because fewer than 10% of their listings were in stock.
A check on the day count. Our BGASC and Provident reviews counted only the 33 gold days and 20 silver days when every dealer was fully tracked. On that stricter basis, Money Metals was still the most frequent winner on random-year Krugerrands (18 of 32 days). On specific-year Gold Maples it won 5 of 32 days to BGASC's 28. Its Gold Eagle and Silver Eagle results didn't change. When we compared Money Metals against every dealer, including those that rarely have stock, BullionExchanges and GoldenStateMint took most Krugerrand days. Both post low prices on listings that are rarely in stock or unverified.
What changed since June. Our first review, published June 19, 2026, used 60 to 65 days of data through June 15, premiums against each dealer's own displayed spot, whole product categories rather than random-year and specific-year coins, and every dealer as a competitor, including GoldenStateMint. Under that method, Money Metals looked like it never won on Krugerrands. It also looked like it won outright on several niche coins that no other dealer stocked. This version replaces those findings. Full methodology →
Last updated: October 24, 2026. Premium data through October 11, 2026.