Methodology

How BullionMetric Tracks Premium Data

BullionMetric tracks every major US bullion dealer's daily pricing across 60+ product categories. Premium-over-spot is computed at ingest time and stored on every observation, so when we report that a dealer was “lowest premium on X days out of 60,” we're reading from a denormalized field on the raw price history table — not a model estimate.

Scrape cadence

We scrape each tracked dealer roughly 5 days per week. A “90-day” tracking window therefore yields ~60–65 distinct observation dates per dealer, not 90. We describe windows as “60+ days over the last ~3 months” in editorial content to keep the framing accurate.

Premium computation

For each product observation, premium = (dealer price − spot price) / spot price. We filter observations to the0 ≤ percent_over_spot ≤ 100band to exclude data-quality outliers (negative premiums from stale spot snapshots, extreme commemoratives over 1,000% markup). We also restrict to in-stock products: a price you can't actually buy at isn't a price.

On category dealer rankings, Best Deal Today, the answer blocks and the fair price band, premiums are measured against each dealer’s own spot price at the moment we capture the price. If a dealer shows no spot price, or one that’s far from what other dealers show at the same time, we use the median of the other dealers’ spot prices instead. We’ll move to a single shared intraday spot reference soon.

“Lowest premium dealer on a given day”

For each category, each day, we compute every tracked dealer's median premium across that category's in-stock products. The dealer with the lowest category median for that day wins the day for that category. A dealer that isn't carrying any in-stock products in a category that day simply doesn't participate — we don't penalize them with a high “default” value.

Peer set

The current dealer-review peer set is 11 dealers: Money Metals Exchange, APMEX, JM Bullion, SD Bullion, BullionExchanges, BGASC, Hero Bullion, GoldenStateMint, Provident Metals, SilverGoldBull, and Kitco. Two dealers (GoldenStateMint at ~23 tracked products and Kitco at ~91) carry narrower catalogs than the major-8 and should be read as specialists when they show up as winning a category. We include them with that asterisk rather than excluding them — excluding any dealer with strong data invites valid “cherry-picked” criticism.

Golden State Mint is excluded from cheapest-dealer claims: its listings report in stock almost without exception, which we can't verify. A dealer we call cheapest has to be one you can actually buy from.

Refresh cadence on reviews

Dealer-review articles are refreshed quarterly. The “Last updated” date on each review and thedateModifiedfield in the page's JSON-LD both pull from the database row'smodified_atcolumn — never hardcoded. If a refresh materially changes a dealer's standing on a key product, we update the verdict section accordingly.