Buyer Guides

Where Is the Cheapest Place to Buy Silver? 15 Months of Prices From 11 Dealers

By BullionMetric

Disclosure. BullionMetric has no affiliate or commercial relationship with any dealer named on this page, and no dealer pays for placement or rankings. If we join affiliate programs in the future, we'll say so on this page and on our affiliate disclosure page, with the date it began.

The short answer: it depends less on the dealer than on what you buy. Per ounce of silver, circulated 90% junk silver was the cheapest silver we tracked: $3.83–4.07 an ounce below a random-year 1 oz coin at the same dealer. If you want one-ounce pieces, a generic round beat every coin. And on Silver Eagles, JM Bullion and SD Bullion were the dealers most often cheapest.

These answers come from 15 months of prices, June 2025 to August 2026, across 11 online dealers. Every comparison is like for like: the same dealer in the same month, or different dealers on the same day at the same time of capture. The full method is in our State of Retail Bullion Premiums report.

The cheapest form of silver

Here's every form of silver we could measure, against a random-year 1 oz coin at the same dealer in the same month:

SilverPer ounce, against a random-year 1 oz coin
90% dimes and quarters$3.83–4.07 cheaper
Mixed 90%$3.85–4.11 cheaper
100 oz bar$2.04–2.05 cheaper
Kilo bar$1.11–1.22 cheaper
Generic 1 oz roundabout $0.96 cheaper
10 oz bar$0.34–0.52 cheaper
1 oz barabout the same
The cheapest ounce of silver isn't a coin or a bar: per ounce of silver against a random-year 1 oz coin at the same dealer, 90% dimes and quarters were $3.83–4.07 cheaper, mixed 90% $3.85–4.11, a 100 oz bar $2.04–2.05, a kilo bar $1.11–1.22, a 1 oz round about $0.96 and a 10 oz bar $0.34–0.52; a 1 oz bar was about the same.

Junk silver is priced on the silver it contains: 0.715 oz per $1 of face value for circulated 90% coin. The bar figures cover new-production bars; secondhand bars are a separate market with too few dealers for a firm figure.

If you're stacking for the metal: junk 90% is the cheapest ounce. For one-ounce pieces, buy generic rounds. For larger amounts, a 100 oz bar saves about $2 an ounce over random-year coins; a 10 oz bar saves much less.

The cheapest silver coin

If you want a sovereign coin, the random-year Philharmonic was the cheapest 1 oz silver coin in 11 of 14 months.

TierSilver coin (1 oz, random-year)Typical premium
1Philharmonic11.28%
2Kangaroo, Krugerrand, Britannia12.29–12.92%
3Maple Leaf13.46%
4Eagle15.71%
5Libertad22.44%

Coins in the same tier swap places from month to month, so they're grouped rather than numbered. A generic 1 oz round was cheaper still, by $0.61–0.63 an ounce against the Philharmonic.

Random-year beats dated, every time

A dated coin cost more than the random-year version on every silver coin we measured, in every phase of the market. On a Silver Eagle, a coin dated 2024 or earlier cost about $6.44 more than random-year, and the gap ran from 5.5 to 22.5 percentage points depending on the dealer. On a Silver Maple Leaf it was about $4.78; on a Silver Britannia, $3.39–4.06. The Philharmonic's was the smallest, at $0.60–0.67.

A 2025-dated Silver Eagle cost about as much extra as an older date: about $4.50 more than random-year.

The cheapest dealer for each silver coin

We compared dealers on the same random-year coin, on the same day, at the same time of capture.

Silver coinMost often cheapest
Silver EagleJM Bullion before February 2026; SD Bullion after
Silver KrugerrandBGASC
Silver PhilharmonicBGASC
Silver BritanniaSD Bullion
Silver Maple LeafHero Bullion before February 2026; SD Bullion after
Silver KangarooProvident Metals (2026)

On the Silver Eagle, here's what each dealer cost per ounce over the day's cheapest price, at the median:

Silver Eagle (1 oz, random-year)Median extra per ounce over the day's cheapest
SD Bullion$0.61
JM Bullion$0.64
Provident Metals$2.38
Kitco$2.74
Money Metals Exchange$3.53
Apmex$4.79
Same Silver Eagle, same day: median extra per ounce over the day's cheapest dealer was $0.61 at SD Bullion, $0.64 at JM Bullion, $2.38 at Provident Metals, $2.74 at Kitco, $3.53 at Money Metals Exchange and $4.79 at Apmex.

Comparing dealers on the day saved a typical buyer about $2.37 an ounce on Silver Eagles. That's the gap between the middle dealer and the cheapest, not the best case.

Golden State Mint often lists the lowest premium on Silver Eagles in our data, but its listings show as in stock almost every day, which we can't verify. We don't rank it as the cheapest dealer. Confirm availability before you count on its price.

What doesn't save money

  • Tubes and monster boxes. A Silver Eagle tube cost $3.09 an ounce more than random-year singles at the same dealer, and a monster box $1.07–3.37 more.
  • A 1 oz silver bar instead of a coin. About the same. For one ounce, buy a round.
  • Graded Silver Eagles. About $47–48 more than a random-year one. That's a collector purchase.
  • Waiting for a particular weekday. No day of the week was reliably cheapest.
  • Paying by card. At Apmex and JM Bullion, the check/wire price is 4% below the card price. Every price on this page is the check/wire price for one unit.

Today's prices

These are 15-month findings. For today's cheapest dealer on a specific coin, use the comparison tool. Our report has the full detail, including gold.

Buying gold? See how much over spot to pay for gold →

For what a fair silver premium is per ounce, see how much over spot to pay for silver →

Frequently asked questions

Where is the cheapest place to buy silver online?

It depends on what you buy. Per ounce of silver, circulated 90% junk silver was the cheapest form we tracked, $3.83–4.07 an ounce below a random-year 1 oz coin at the same dealer. For one-ounce pieces, a generic round beat every coin. For Silver Eagles, JM Bullion and SD Bullion were most often the cheapest dealers over 15 months of tracking, June 2025 to August 2026.

Who has the lowest premium on Silver Eagles?

Over 15 months, JM Bullion was most often cheapest on random-year Silver Eagles before February 2026, and SD Bullion after. At the median, SD Bullion ran $0.61 an ounce over the day's cheapest dealer and JM Bullion $0.64, against $4.79 at Apmex. Golden State Mint often lists lower prices, but its stock status can't be verified, so we don't rank it.

What's the cheapest 1 oz silver coin?

The random-year Philharmonic, the cheapest 1 oz silver coin in 11 of 14 months. A generic 1 oz round was cheaper still, by $0.61–0.63 an ounce against the Philharmonic. The Silver Eagle sat in the fourth silver tier.

Is junk silver cheaper than silver coins?

Yes. Circulated 90% dimes and quarters cost $3.83–4.07 less per ounce of silver than a random-year 1 oz silver coin at the same dealer, and that held in every phase of the market. Junk silver is priced on its silver content: 0.715 oz per $1 of face value.

Are silver bars cheaper than coins?

At one ounce, no: a new 1 oz bar cost about the same as a random-year coin. Bigger bars were cheaper per ounce: a 10 oz bar by $0.34–0.52, a kilo by $1.11–1.22 and a 100 oz bar by $2.04–2.05, against a random-year 1 oz coin at the same dealer.

Are monster boxes and tubes cheaper per ounce?

No. A Silver Eagle tube cost $3.09 an ounce more than random-year singles at the same dealer, and a monster box $1.07–3.37 more. That's against the single-coin price, the most a dealer charges per coin.

Does Apmex have the cheapest silver?

Not on Silver Eagles. Apmex's median price ran $4.79 an ounce above the day's cheapest dealer, the widest gap of the six dealers we could compare, and it wasn't the most often cheapest dealer on any silver coin we ranked.

Does JM Bullion have the cheapest silver?

On random-year Silver Eagles, often. JM Bullion was the dealer most often cheapest before February 2026, and its median price ran $0.64 an ounce over the day's cheapest across the full 15 months.

Is it cheaper to pay by check or wire?

Usually. At Apmex and JM Bullion, the check/wire price is 4% below the card price. Every price in our data is the check/wire price for one unit.

Is Costco silver a good deal?

We don't track Costco: its prices are visible only to members. To judge any Costco price, compare it with today's spot price and with online dealer prices on BullionMetric.